- as Michael Finkel
- as Christian Longo
- as Jill Barker
- as MaryJane Longo
- as Pat Frato
- as Greg Ganley
- as Judge Odenkirk
- as Karen Hannen
- as Cheryl Frank
- as Blaise
- as Jeffrey Gregg
- as Coroner
- as Jack Pool
- as Tina Alvis
- as Courtroom Sheriff
- as Corey Douglas
- as Zak Rausch
- as Steve Mensah
- as Jail Receptionist
- as Marcus Lickermann
- as Ibrahim
- as Maureen Duffy
- as Visiting Room Guard
- as Police Officer
- as Dan Pegg
- as Reporter
- as Beth Tickler
- as Colin Parker
- as Mr. Longo
- as Mrs. Longo
- as Young Man
- as Lincoln County Lobby Sheriff
- as Older Man
- as Female MSU Worker
- as Male MSU Worker
- as Middle-Aged Man
- as Middle-Aged Woman
- as Ellen Parks
- as Geoffrey J. Ploobtark
Watch "True Story":